Big Ten Roundtable: Illustrating The Rivalries
Thanks to Gopher Nation for the questions.
1. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg recently ranked the top 5 rivalries in the Big Ten and there were some controversial results (Illinois v Ohio State as #3?). Clearly Ohio State vs. Michigan is the #1 rivalry in the Big Ten, but give me your next three. Your school does not have to be included in this list, but regardless of who you choose defend your picks.
It's common knowledge that, by default, Penn State does not actually have any rivals in the Big Ten. Never mind that several of our games rank in the Top 5 in TV ratings, our 'rivalry' game is Michigan State, and because that is one of the worst rivalries in sports, the rest of our games are clearly meaningless.
So with that in mind, I'm ranking this thing the only way I know how: by coolest trophy.
1. Slab of Bacon - Minnesota v Wisconsin - This, the coolest of Big Ten trophies was somehow lost in the '40s, soon to be replaced by Paul Bunyan's Axe in 1948.
From what I've gathered, the original trophy looked something like this:


After it rotted in the Wisconsin clubhouse during 1930, a more stable replacement was needed:

2. Sweet Sioux Tomahawk - Northwestern v Illinois - Not even sure what this means to be honest, and what makes a tomahawk sweet? Anyway, points for creativity and inclusion of Northwestern.
Update: So here is the story.
The student newspapers at Northwestern and Illinois birthed the idea of the two football teams playing for a wooden Indian trophy in 1945. The name of the trophy was "Sweet Sioux." The following year, the trophy was stolen from a showcase at Northwestern. So, in 1947, a tomahawk was instituted as the traveling trophy. Incidentally, Sweet Sioux was found in 1948 but because of its size, it was discarded and the teams continue to play for the tomahawk to this day.
3. Land Grant Trophy - Penn State v Michigan State - Ok, I'm not actually serious but Penn State was making this list somehow and it certainly wasn't going to be because of the Governor's Victory Bell. Update for you all, via Wikipedia of course: the rivalry was actually started over a stamp.

But this wouldn't be a post without a picture of the trophy, a true engineering marvel.

2. Obviously winning every game is important and beating really good teams sends a stronger message than beating Minnesota. Assume every team is .500 this year and the outcome of your next two games means nothing outside of pride and a year's worth of bragging rights. Give me the two schools you would want to beat (in order) and why. What makes beating School's A and B significant?
Michigan, of course, because of the streak. Other than that, ummmm, Indiana, because...of the streak. Ya, Indiana.
3. Take the two teams from above that you claim are your biggest rivals and give me a new mascot for them.
Michigan is easy.

As for Indiana, I had to go a little further in the archives.

4. There are some new rules in college football this year. My favorite is the Big Ten experimental rule which states that after every win this year you get to pluck one player off their roster and bring them back to your campus. Looking at your schedule give me two players you would pluck (assuming a win), why you would take them and what would you do with them?
Well there is one gaping hole I'm worried about on the PSU roster and that is the corner position. When I look around the Big Ten, I don't see any major upgrades at any other spot (conditional, of course, on Clark/Devlin being able to perform at an average level). So with that being said, I'm taking Jenkins from OSU and Davis from Illinois.
5. Brian at MGO was kind enough to post a diary entry which gives us and new coach Rich Rodriguez a list of Michigan traditions that maybe we were not all aware of. This has inspired two final questions...
5A - are there any Michigan traditions that he missed? (here is your chance for some Michigan cheap shots)
This is easy: consistently being the most over-rated team in football.
5B - Are there any traditions of your school's rival that we should all be aware of?
Just one.
0 recs |
27 comments
Comments
Oh, that trophy.
PSU/Thon should sell raffle tickets with the winner getting to destroy the Land Grant Trophy on the 50 yard line at Beaver Stadium.
by Run Up The Score on
Aug 5, 2008 3:09 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Unrealistic
My suggestion: winner of the raffle gets to add something to the trophy. Every year. Might as well own the hideousness.
by M1EK on
Aug 6, 2008 11:04 AM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
this is a great idea. with all the shelves it perfect for that type of over the top ugliness.
Kevin @ Black Shoe Diaries
by Kevin HD on
Aug 6, 2008 11:28 AM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Trophy
They should fight for Abe Lincoln’s Hat since Lincoln was the one that signed the land grants. How funny would it be to see Abe Koroma dancing on the 50 with a Top Hat on his head and a fake Abe Lincoln beard?
Mike
Black Shoe Diaries
by BSD on
Aug 6, 2008 12:16 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Abe Lincoln Koroma
Please, someone with photoshop skills make it happen.
by Screen Name 20 on
Aug 6, 2008 1:13 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Honest Abe Koroma
Honestly…he’s gonna sack you!

And, yes, I know that’s not a QB he’s tackling. It was the best picture I could find.
I bleed Blue and White.
by Horse N Buggy on
Aug 6, 2008 5:02 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Dateline: November 22, 2008
Defensive End Maurice Evans sports the newly redesigned “Abe Lincoln Land Grant Trophy” while signing autographs.
by Cairo on
Aug 6, 2008 7:53 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
ummm
that’s effing awesome.
Kevin @ Black Shoe Diaries
by Kevin HD on
Aug 6, 2008 9:04 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I'm still gigglin' about this picture
Fine job of photoshopping, Cairo
by NJ lion on
Aug 6, 2008 9:49 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
That. Rocks.
Ladies and gentlemen, (and you too RUTS.) we have a new trophy.
Mike
Black Shoe Diaries
by BSD on
Aug 6, 2008 11:17 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
World's ugliest trophy!
Why couldn’t it have been something cool like an axe or or a beer stein or even a bronze pig?
by NJ lion on
Aug 5, 2008 3:12 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Something cool
They probably went wrong in letting MSU football coach George Pearles design it.
Mike
Black Shoe Diaries
by BSD on
Aug 5, 2008 3:24 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
sweet!
Great work, Kevin! Geez, where to start? And here I thought Paul Bunyan’s axe was the coolest trophy in the Big Ten: to learn it replaced a slab of bacon kinda pains me. Bring back the bacon!
Great shots of corso. At first glance I thought it was Carmine from Laverne & Shirley, then maybe the nextdoor neighbor dad from That Seventies Show?
Love the Snake Oil Salesman!
And who can get enough of JohnL’s self-bitchslap?
An absolutely beautiful collage…..
Convivite Nudem!
by jtothep on
Aug 5, 2008 3:16 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
that slap
is a youtube classic that will live on forever. just awesome.
Kevin @ Black Shoe Diaries
by Kevin HD on
Aug 5, 2008 4:34 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
TCU and SMU play for the Iron Skillet. It’s a pretty cool trophy. Has anyone seen the Governor’s Victory Bell trophy between Penn State and Minnesota? Slightly better than the Land Grant trophy, but it still looks like an arts and crafts project.
John
by Johnnyrad10 on
Aug 5, 2008 10:18 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
the land grant trophy
It wouldn’t be that horrible except on the top they put a golden guy (you know he is made of plastic). I think we should win it and donate it to be the new fulmer cup/trophy.
Boom goes the dynamite.
by psu on
Aug 5, 2008 4:09 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Most Over Rated
That is the most retarded way anyone could possibly rank the most over rated teams of all time.
Its a comparison of different polls pre-season and post season and he changes how he determines what the preseason ranking is after the first four years.
by DrDetroit on
Aug 5, 2008 4:12 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
ya, but i had to include it
it’s all just a shot at ND if I remember right.
Kevin @ Black Shoe Diaries
by Kevin HD on
Aug 5, 2008 4:32 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Stassen
Yeah, it seems like it. Chris Stassen has some great polling statistics, but that list is so obviously flawed that it’s like he leaves it up on his webpage just to provoke flame wars.
by gumbercules on
Aug 5, 2008 6:00 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
That slab of bacon looked pretty damn good to me.
If I could have that, I’d kill somebody to get meat like that for free.
24 DAYS 17 HOURS 32 MINUTES 41 SECONDS UNTIL OPENING KICKOFF.
by Ab4PSU on
Aug 5, 2008 6:27 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
F--- Indiana!
ClapClap ClapClapClap
I googled Lee Corso to see if there was a picture from when he took a picture of the scoreboard when Indiana had a lead on Ohio State. One of my favorite stories ever.
by speedomike on
Aug 5, 2008 9:59 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
2004's
squeaker win over Indiana was the biggest impetus for that great ‘05 run.
Had they been able to punch it in at the end, would 2005 have been the same?
'People are about as happy as they decide they want to be'
by Pete the Streak on
Aug 6, 2008 6:23 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
that was awesome
1st and 2 at PSU 2 Chris Taylor (IU) rushed up the middle for no gain.
2nd and 2 at PSU 2 Chris Taylor (IU) rushed up the middle for -1 yards.
3rd and 3 at PSU 3 Nittany Lions timeout; 01:11 remaining 4th quarter
3rd and 3 at PSU 3 Matt LoVecchio (IU) rushed up the middle for 1 yard.
4th and 2 at PSU 2 Nittany Lions timeout; 00:59 remaining 4th quarter
4th and 2 at PSU 2 Chris Taylor (IU) rushed up the middle for 1 yard; turnover on downs.
Kevin @ Black Shoe Diaries
by Kevin HD on
Aug 6, 2008 8:28 AM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Penn State Rivalry
I think there are three reasons Penn State doesn’t have a B10 rival.
1. 2000 through 2004. You can’t have a rivalry without being a good team. I think this more than anything hurt PSU rivalry games. Then when PSU recovered, the B10 collapsed.
2. No big upsets or win streaks. The start of a rivalry would be by ruining someone else’s season. Like the year Michigan State won at #1 Ohio State. Then you have to back that up by having consistently good games against that team and being a good team (unlike MSU). Also, beating any better B10 team 3 or more years in a row would also be a big start.
3. Michigan State. What was looking to be a good rivalry by the late 90s fell apart with MSU. With MSU now realizing that football goes beyond September this could indeed be a big rivalry soon. All that has to happen is for MSU to keep improving and have the season ending game mean something. If things go right for both teams this year the game with MSU could be for a BCS Bowl. If that happens, hello rivalry! Or if this happens to be JoePa’s last year, a MSU victory ruining Joe’s last game in Happy Valley would really light a fire in the rivalry.
by DrDetroit on
Aug 6, 2008 9:50 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
That Land Grant Trophy
looks like a Ken & Barbie dollhouse my daughter had once. It’s got a little terrace, two decks, and rooftop sunbathing area. I think it’s a great idea to celebrate the founding of the schools by calling it the Land Grant Trophy, but it seems they could have put more thought into the design. Work with 1855, say, when both schools were founded.
by jerseywilds on
Aug 6, 2008 1:51 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs














