Blasphemous Question

I’ll take DC17. He fits the Spread HD….Tebow would be exposed with that very slow delivery.

I’ve never been sold on McCoy (did you know he once saved a man from drowning)

Tebow = Sean McHugh

Joe would waste his talent with bubble screens and four yard out patterns.

I think Penn State this year would do equally well with Clark or OMG TEBOW.

Sorry, I love DC17 but I think it’s delusional to think he’s a better QB (not player, QB) than Tebow or McCoy. I think the PSU fan base has way overrated DC – he still has a long way to go – and there is no proof that he is going to get there. I hope he does, but there is no realism about his development.

but he’s not a miracle worker. You are what you are with any of these guys. It’s the curse of the spread…makes mediocre guys look good from far, even though they are far from good….and it suppresses the abilities of truly talented QBs. There’s a reason G. Harrell is in the CFL and Vince Young is charting plays in Nashville.

but I really don’t see how Tebow is a good QB, unless the jump pass is a legitimate QB weapon, and not just a stupid mistake. Somehow he’s been able to minimize any negatives, though, even though I swear he looks like an average QB at best. If you want to say that he’s a great QB for his system…perhaps, but I wouldn’t want him running our offense. Maybe if we had him, we’d adjust the offense to his skills, but I don’t really like that offense. Then again, if we had him, he’d be playing FB.

McCoy I think is probably the best passing QB at a high profile school, and he actually has some pretty good quickness as well. I’d take him over Tebow, and maybe over Clark.

As of yet, Clark hasn’t done much to make me dislike him, or think he’s any worse than Tebow. He’s essentially had one bad game in his career as a starter, and that was Iowa last year where he was apparently still feeling the effects of his concussion, and the conditions were terrible for any QB to perform well in.

7-7 in each game. The guy can throw.

But not respecting him as one of the greatest college players of the modern era is just dumb.