Jim Caldwell Is Somehow Still Under The Radar

Who the bleep is Jim Caldwell?
Jim Caldwell was the guy on your TV Sunday night not showing any emotion. The guy who looked like he forgot he was coaching one of the greatest quarterbacks ever to play in the Super Bowl (probably no coincidence, as you'll be told later).
He's the guy that was doing this despite once being pushed out of the frickin' Wake Forest job. A guy who went 12-52 in league play at that school and called it "maybe one of the greatest experiences of my life."
He's a guy who "knows shadows." He's just recently stepped out of those metaphoric shadows. Although not really.
He is both liked and respected:
Howard Mudd, the Colts' longtime offensive line coach, said, "The best story here isn't Dwight," referring to the injured defensive end Dwight Freeney, who will attempt to play. "It isn't Peyton. It's Jim Caldwell."
What does this have to do with me?
I'll step away from the annoying tone and start with Frank Bodani's homework:
Joe Paterno hired him. Fran Ganter guided him. Bill Kenney and Dick Anderson worked alongside him. Jay Paterno played under him.
And Larry Johnson Sr. looked to him as a mentor and roomed with him while working Penn State's summer camps.
Cladwell served as the quarterbacks coach for seven years, no short stint for a position worker, and worked with Kerry Collins, Matt Knizner, and a couple of Saccas. And Jay Paterno.
He's apparently pretty good at his work:
"If you take Peyton Manning's stats before Jim Caldwell got there - 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001 - and after Caldwell got there, it's a startling difference," [Dungy] said. "Look at interceptions, quarterback rating, touchdowns to interceptions, wins, losses, from when Jim started coaching him to now, it'll be eye-opening."
To get to the answer: Jim Caldwell is a football coach with Penn State ties, and by all accounts he's very good at what he does.
But the college game, it's different. What makes you think he can recruit like Nick Saban?
And therein lies Caldwell's greatest asset: he can't, and won't, recruit like Nick Saban. Nothing should make you happier.
Caldwell is the kind of guy who says things like, "But nevertheless it still boils down to they have an outstanding football team and so do we."
The kind of guy who "To make a correction...is more likely to get in a player's face."
Alright sorry I'll stop. He's going to do things the Penn State way. It's going to be harder and harder to find people both successful and willing who aren't also undesirable shades of Urban Meyer.
Hey crack smoker, no seemingly-successful NFL coach who just took a trip to the Super Bowl is going to want to coach your school.
Meh, things change. Coaching is a fickle profession and if anyone wants to start making bets that pay when coaching ends in stability, well I'll take that action every time save one. (Well maybe two. Maybe.)
Look at Jim Tressel, arguable the most stable active coach still holding down the fort. He was lampooned for using a quarterback who went to Ohio State specifically to be used that way, and it took the Big Ten's first Rose Bowl win in 10 years to return everyone back to "oh sky is not falling" mode.
All I'm saying: you're one Failsman against Proverbial Purdue away from losing the mob. You lose the mob? You lose everything, and it often happens quickly.
So Caldwell lost this one...maybe he makes another mistake next season and then again in the playoffs. All of the sudden Indy isn't winning championships and Peytonville isn't happy. I wish the man success, not failure, but I can't control events and if things go mediocre, well all of the sudden Caldwell is available.
I'm going to irrationally take this as an insult to Scrap and LJSR. What do you have against two lifers who deserve it?
Nothing, you irrational fictitious blogging crutch. Bradley and Johnson's successes are well documented here and their front-runner status is no sham.
However, when the time comes, let's take the camera out of narrow angle view.
35 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Great article on Caldwell
But that Paterno video gets me every time. God I love that man.
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
Probably one of my favorite videos of all time
The part that strikes me the most isn’t the running full speed to scold someone, or pushing a lineman two times his height out of the way to show him the right way to hit. It’s the Paul Cianciolo part. The man is so dedicated to bringing “raising” these guys, he’s giving tips to the 3rd string QB who he knows has essentially zero chance of ever starting a game in blue and white or making it in the pros, yet he still takes the time to make sure that Paul does everything perfectly as if he’s going to be starting.
He's like Ferentz, but without the gum chewing.
Want.
"I AM A DIEHARD REDSKINS FAN, CAPS, LEAFS, AND I LOVE WATCHING TENNIS. SO WHATS THE BIG DEAL"
Meh
We’re going to get Dungy for our next HC, book it done.
"We hugged as grown men do. It was a great moment. Then, it was business as usual." -- LJ Sr.
I saw Bill Cowher at the Tavern.
/rumor’d
"I'm colonel cool! And I'm the captain on this rocket to the stars!"
“This is BSD, not Audibles. This is BSD, not Audibles.”
Ok, now what were we talking about?
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 9:58 AM EST up reply actions
i heard a rumor he has recently bought property on happy valley
Never insult seven men when all you have is a six shooter --COL Sherman T Potter
by psu in the w-b on Feb 10, 2010 9:34 PM EST up reply actions
Ferentz is a PA guy!....
"I AM A DIEHARD REDSKINS FAN, CAPS, LEAFS, AND I LOVE WATCHING TENNIS. SO WHATS THE BIG DEAL"
by ReadingRambler on Feb 10, 2010 9:45 AM EST up reply actions
My brother went to school with his daughter or niece, I can't remember.
Go Peters!
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 9:59 AM EST up reply actions
He is my father's brother's nephew's cousin's former roommate.
by VVeRPennState on Feb 10, 2010 10:19 AM EST up reply actions
So what does that make us?
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 10:40 AM EST up reply actions
excellent

Never insult seven men when all you have is a six shooter --COL Sherman T Potter
by psu in the w-b on Feb 10, 2010 9:35 PM EST up reply actions
I saw "The Chin"
at CC Peppers and he sucked!
That's not funny.
"I AM A DIEHARD REDSKINS FAN, CAPS, LEAFS, AND I LOVE WATCHING TENNIS. SO WHATS THE BIG DEAL"
by ReadingRambler on Feb 10, 2010 10:16 AM EST up reply actions
DOES NOT WANT.
There are maybe 2 or 3 scenarios in the world where I’d abandon my PSU allegiance. This may be one of them.
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 10:17 AM EST up reply actions
My scenarios:
Kiffin.
Major uniform change.
JoePa fired after “mediocre” 8-4 season.
"I AM A DIEHARD REDSKINS FAN, CAPS, LEAFS, AND I LOVE WATCHING TENNIS. SO WHATS THE BIG DEAL"
by ReadingRambler on Feb 10, 2010 10:20 AM EST up reply actions
Daniel Snyder.
So what’s the big deal?
And nice call on Isaiah.
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 10:42 AM EST up reply actions
not to worry, he'd be here for 10 months, tops.
by Cairo on Feb 10, 2010 10:20 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Rec'd, of course.
But still, it would be like hiring Calipari. I’d be ashamed to go in public with PSU clothing.
"I AM A DIEHARD REDSKINS FAN, CAPS, LEAFS, AND I LOVE WATCHING TENNIS. SO WHATS THE BIG DEAL"
by ReadingRambler on Feb 10, 2010 10:21 AM EST up reply actions
And after going 6-6 he'd get the Yankees job or something.
Somehow this genius has found a tear in the common sense fabric of the sporting world where mediocrity gets you a raise. I gotta find the legal version of that and malpractice my way to a Reed Smith partner position.
"Have I ever told the story of when I met Miley Cyrus?"
by Jeff Junstrom on Feb 10, 2010 10:45 AM EST up reply actions
If this happens I will travel to the Paterno statue and do this in a sign of protest

I am Laura Nichols and I like Bacon.
BSD is an addiction, and this is the first step.
by carolinaeasy on Feb 10, 2010 11:01 AM EST up reply actions
Nothing like memories of Vietnam War era self-immolation to cheer one up.
"Never mistake motion for action." - Ernest Hemingway
I wasn't trying to be cheery
I would figuratively set fire to my PSU fandom if they hired Lane.
I am Laura Nichols and I like Bacon.
BSD is an addiction, and this is the first step.
by carolinaeasy on Feb 11, 2010 7:49 AM EST up reply actions
Kiffen
must have pictures from the company picnic or as I like to put it, what in hell did he do to become a reality show star…porno film—-marry up——become Skins4ever ???
by DerryPharmer on Feb 10, 2010 11:01 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
I agree hard with this article.
If LJSr or Scrap become our next HC, I will be happy with that. Just dandy actually.
However, I don’t think it should just automatically be handed to them. There are a few of intriguing options for PSU when Joe hangs it up. Now, I never want to grab someone who doesn’t share the same principles as Joe, but just because someone isn’t on our current staff doesn’t mean they will tear everything down a la dickrod when they come in.
I’m just saying, we should peek around a little bit. Look at Caldwell, look at Golden, look at Scrap, LJ, Schiano, Spaziani, Cowher, Dungy, Ferentz, etc etc. Just check it out and see, even if it isn’t likely to work out.
I do feel like the HC job will be handed down to the current staff, I am fine with that, but we shouldn’t be too short sighted.
Black Shoes. Basic Blues. No Name. All Game.
"Everyone has a plan, until they get punched in the mouth."
No love for Al Golden?
This would be my order:
LJ Sr.
Golden
Scrap
Caldwell
Oh my word
So many gems you threw in there, Kevin. Not time enough to comment on all of em….so I picked just two:
1. That Saban article was fascinating. Fascinating! Couldn’t believe it. How has this not gotten more attention?
Gillett excuses Saban because all he’s done is win and winning doesn’t seem like a crime. Apparently he’s missed the last four signing days, when Alabama’s signed 25, 32, 27, and 29 players. This is 113 players, which you will note is slightly larger than the 85 you’re allowed to have on the roster. Every year there are stories headlined “Attrition likely to continue for Crimson Tide” that detail a rash of transfers and dubious medical scholarships. This is because every year Alabama goes into the offseason way, way over the 85 limit and has to slash its way down. Whether the cuts are explicit or not, the mathematical inevitability is clear: if you go to Alabama you will either start or get the axe.
Links from the block quote: link1….link2 I highly recommend reading all the links contained in the Saban article Kevin posted above. Please. We all need to be this informed for our upcoming clashes with our old rivals down south.
2. JoePa at practice is a thing of sheer beauty. I could watch a marathon of that kind of footage.
"We just forgot our pants. Nothing against the team or anything like that." -- take a guess
I wouldn't mind Caldwell
but my preference is LJ Sr.
I agree with brd119’s list… I’d probably throw Caldwell ahead of Bradley and below Bradley I’d put Jay Paterno
LJ Sr.
Golden
Caldwell
Bradley
Jay Paterno
Vanderlinden
Schiano
\Obviously I was really impressed with Caldwell
not to dismiss lifers
but there is something to be said about psu experience plus outside experience Caldwell would be an interesting otpion
Never insult seven men when all you have is a six shooter --COL Sherman T Potter
by psu in the w-b on Feb 10, 2010 10:08 PM EST reply actions
Caldwell......
meh. Is he a hands on head coach or more like the CEO ? Manning and Mora clearly run the offense. He “coached” that Super Bowl very conservatively and not to lose, which, if I wanted to be a smart a**, I could say makes him a perfect fit for PSU. We’ve never seen PSU play a big game ultra conservatively, have we?
With that being said, by all accounts, he is a man of high character. I’d trade some character for coaching ability.
Never mistake effort for achievement.
by Esteban d' Amur on Feb 11, 2010 7:56 AM EST reply actions

by 

























