Both were 1st team AA's, both clowned on Ohio State. Here are the stats that they recorded:
Hali (2005): 11 sacks, 17 TFL's, 65 tackles
Maybin (2008): 12 sacks, 20 TFL's, 49 tackles
I went with Hali though, he seemed to step up at bigger times in the bigger games, Maybin would show up, but he wouldn't be a force like Hali was (IE: 4 sacks vs Wisconsin.) Didn't factor in NFL production in this.
Tamba Hali (160 votes)
Aaron Maybin (3 votes)
163 total votes