This one should be close (Or at least I hope it will). Here are the (Somewhat incomplete) Stats:
Shipley- 3 year starter, 2x 1st team All Big Ten Center, 1x 1st Team AA, Rimington Award winner
Wisniewski- 4 year starter, 2x 2nd team All Big Ten, 1x 1st team All Big Ten, 1x 3rd team AA, 1x 2nd team AA, 3x 1st team Academic All American
Wisniewski never had a year quite like Shipley's in 2008, but Shipley never had a career like Stefen's (Not a knock on either, to say)
Connect with Black Shoe Diaries