clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Six Reasons Why James Franklin Makes Sense For LSU

Article may or may not be a lazy regurgitation of the same idiocy I said a few weeks ago.

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

NCAA Football: Big Ten Conference Media Days Robert Goddin-USA TODAY Sports

Well friends, it’s that time again. The USC Trojans LSU Tigers have finally fired their head coach, Clay Helton Ed Orgeron. Some might say it was a long time coming, while others wonder why USC LSU did such a foolish thing, instead of extending him for another 10 years. Alas, Helton Orgeron is gone stepping down at the end of the season, and the task is to find another head coach for the Trojans Tigers.

And who better to fill that role than the guy we, the media*, have been hoping and praying for in the last, say, five years? Personally, I couldn’t wait to write this piece, because it simply Makes Sense™ for James From State College to take the job. In fact, it makes so much sense, that USC LSU should leave the position vacant until Franklin finally accepts the job. Here are six reasons why Franklin is the perfect candidate for the Trojans Tigers

James Franklin is a person

Franklin is the perfect candidate for the Trojans Tigers. He is, first of all, a person! A human being, if you may. USC LSU needs a person to fill the job, and if they happen to be a human beings that’s even better. I think this one is pretty clear, so I shouldn’t have to expand on why being a person makes Franklin the perfect candidate.

James Franklin won the Big Ten in 2016

In order to coach at a place like USC LSU, you need to show that you have what it takes to win the conference. Franklin already proved this when he won the Big Ten in his third season with the program, riding the momentum of having beaten Ohio State all the way to the Big Ten championship game.

The problem, of course, is that the win against the Buckeyes was a fluke, so the entire championship was a fluke. At a place like USC LSU, he would have to earn a championship by beating Oregon Alabama and UCLA Georgia (which would be earned), instead of Michigan and Ohio State (which are flukes).

The Nittany Lions then faced the very same USC Trojans he’d be leaving to coach, and, because he was instead the coach of Penn State, he lost that game. Maybe he’d have won that Rose Bowl if he’d been wearing Red and Gold instead of Blue and White.

And that’s why he Makes Sense™ for USC LSU.

James Franklin has a top 5 recruiting class in 2022

Franklin has been building the talent slowly at Penn State, painstakingly going after top recruits, missing on some, but landing on others, to the point where the Nittany Lions sit at 16th in the 247 Talent Composite. Things have finally started to turn a corner for Franklin, and he’s now slated to bring in one of the most talented classes in his tenure at Penn State, and arguably in the history of the rankings era for the Lions.

All that said, USC LSU sits at 10th fifth in that same Talent Composite ranking, and while the roster will have the same kinds of holes he found himself needing to fix at Penn State, it would be well worth it to do it again at USC LSU, because they’re sitting at 10th fifth in the Talent Composite!

James Franklin could win the Big Ten in 2021

The biggest obstacle to Penn State winning the Big Ten year in and year out has been Ohio State. After this Saturday’s a week 2 loss to Oregon, the Buckeyes have looked as mortal as they ever have, leaving the door wide open for the Nittany Lions to earn luck their way into another Big Ten championship. In fact, it was so clear to everyone that they lucked into the championship that the playoff committee kept Penn State out of the playoff that year to send a message.

Of course, the Buckeyes can put it all together come October 30th and make this moot. After all, Penn State is merely 7th 6th in SP+, and while they beat 8th 7th-ranked Wisconsin on the road, it doesn’t count because Wisconsin sucks. Also they lost to 12th-ranked Iowa on the road (it doesn’t count that Clifford went down). It’s going to be a much taller task to beat the 5th 2nd-ranked SP+ team on the road.

Now, at USC, he’d be taking over the 24th-ranked Trojans unranked Tigers and would almost be a shoo-in for the Pac-12 SEC title year after year. All he’d have to do is get through 20th-ranked Arizona State, 19th-ranked Utah, 17th-ranked UCLA, 16th-ranked Oregon to earn. Nick Saban’s Alabama, an Auburn team they already beat this season, Jimbo Fisher and Texas A&M, and, depending on the year, one of Arkansas, Ole Miss, or Mississippi State. They also play a Notre Dame Florida team that has been surprisingly consistent as of late, but when has losing an extra game led to a team missing the playoff?

James Franklin is a Pennsylvania guy

In order to recruit well in California Louisiana, you need someone like Franklin, who has spent most of his career in the east coast. He’s from Pennsylvania, played for a team in Pennsylvania, started his coaching career in Pennsylvania, has recruiting relationships all over the east coast, and has a coaching staff composed almost exclusively of east coast guys.

That said, he spent a year at Washington State and Idaho State in 1998 and 99, respectively, started his head coaching career at Vanderbilt, an SEC team, which proves that he can have success moving to the south and starting those relationships anew. Moreover, recruiting at USC LSU is going to be a lot easier than at Penn State, so he’ll just need to show up and the relationships will build themselves!

James Franklin likes a challenge

Franklin’s love for a rebuild started off as an assistant at Maryland. While there, he helped build the Terrapins into a competitive team. He continued that trend at Vanderbilt, where he made three consecutive bowl games upon taking the job, which is almost as many bowls as the Commodores had made in their entire history, that number being four.

With Vanderbilt being rebuilt, Franklin knew his job was done. So he took an opportunity to up the ante and take over a team that was in the middle of arguably the worst sanctions handed to any team since SMU got the death penalty.** And what did he do at Penn State? Well, you’ve read reasons two to six, you already know what he’s done. So, why wouldn’t it make sense for Franklin to start all over at USC LSU, the juicy potential of another rebuild having to beat Nick Saban year after year*** just waiting for him to say the word?

We all know James a good thing going at Penn State, and he’s worked extremely hard to get the Nittany Lions to where they are today. But Franklin would be a fool to stay at a job where he can do exactly what he wants when he can leave for the potential to do the same thing elsewhere with the understanding that the conference he’d be going to has a hard time accomplishing what he wants to accomplish at the moment. That’s why it just Makes Sense™.

*We at Black Shoe Diaries do not consider ourself “the media.” Please respect our privacy in these matters.
**Yes, those sanctions would end up being lifted shortly after he started at the job, but he still felt the effects of a depleted roster.
***One should want to beat the best of the best year in and year out. But there’s a difference between “the best of the best” and “literally the best coach that college football will ever see, but ten thousand miles.”